B.C. revenge website sets off torrent of anger, legal concerns
B.C.'s Justice Minister says 'the case could be revisited' in written statement
A revenge website created by a Burnaby B.C. man set on "destroying" his former wife in Arizona has touched off international outrage and criticism about how well Canadian laws stand up against modern online attacks.
Case could re-open
B.C.'s Justice Minister reacted by saying "the case could be revisited," after CBC aired the story of Patrick Fox and Desiree Capuano.
The couple who separated 14 years ago became locked in a custody wrangle over their son that's culminated in a website that labels Capuano a drug addict and white supremacist.
The website is full of demeaning comments and purports to describe details of Capuano's sex life. Fox was arrested by Burnaby RCMP, but charges of criminal harassment were not approved by Crown Counsel because there was deemed to be no "objective fear for personal safety" in part because of the distance between the pair.
Legal tools are there
An online legal expert reviewed the case for CBC. Kevin Westell said B.C. has the tools to go after online harassment, even if it does not feature outright porn or death threats.
"The fear of personal safety can include psychological safety. If psychological harm is being inflicted by actions that are communicated over a distance, it just simply doesn't matter that this person is far away," said Westell.
The difficulty is a lack of resources for prosecutors, and the challenge of proving complex cases like this one, Westell said.
"The devil is in the details. The devil is in trying to put it all together and being that trial crown that has to put it all together and get witnesses," he added.
B.C.'s justice minister reacts
B.C. Justice Minister Suzanne Anton emailed a statement to CBC saying:
"This government takes online harassment seriously...a prosecution may occur regardless of the form that the alleged harassment takes."
"If the police provide additional evidence that might affect the Crown's decision on whether to approve charges, the case could be revisited," said Anton.
"However, it would be up to police to determine whether to re-submit its original Report to Crown Counsel to the Branch, with any additional evidence included."
Case sparks criticism
The decision not to charge the man who crafted the site in B.C. reveals the limits of the charge of criminal harassment in the digital age, other experts said.
"I do think it's worth having a conversation as a society to find out whether or not 'objective fear for your safety' is in fact the right threshold, when more and more harassment is taking place online," said David Fraser, an internet and privacy lawyer.
"I don't suggest dropping it so low that you just have to hurt somebody's feelings, but maybe that line is a little bit too high in order to deal with significant cases of purposeful harassment."
While experts said the high threshold set by criminal harassment law plays a role, they also urged the Crown and police to take another look at the case.
I don't suggest dropping it so low that you just have to hurt somebody's feelings, but maybe that line is a little bit too high.- David Fraser, internet and privacy lawyer
Isabel Grant, a University of British Columbia law professor and criminal harassment expert, agreed with CBC's expert, saying that courts have said reasonable fear for one's safety also includes psychological safety.
She noted that a recent Twitter harassment trial in Ontario resulted in an acquittal because the judge could not conclude the fear of the two complainants was reasonable. She said the B.C. case appears more egregious and could fall within criminal harassment law.
"When this provision was drafted in the early 1990s, people weren't thinking of cyber abuse. They were thinking of men who are physically following and threatening their former partners."
No objective fear
Fox's site and the couple's email exchanges were also investigated by Burnaby RCMP. In July 2015, Fox was arrested and the RCMP recommended a charge of criminal harassment. The Crown did not approve the charge and Fox was released.
"The actual comments used by the perpetrator in this case, we couldn't conclude that that would cause the complainant to have an objective fear for their personal safety," said Dan McLaughlin, communications counsel for the Criminal Justice Branch.
"In this case, the fact the people live in different countries played a part in that assessment."
Legislation introduced last year that criminalized so-called "revenge porn" did not apply because photos of Capuano with a former partner on the website did not include nudity, he added.
CBC News Investigates
With files from Natalie Clancy and The Canadian Press
- 11520 reading nowAnalysis
Texas photo op or not, Trump has walled himself in — with maybe only one way out of this shutdown
- 21491 reading nowUpdated
Family, advocate speak after video shows CFS seizing newborn in Winnipeg
- 31259 reading nowMARKETPLACE
Canada's major grocery chains slow to tackle the mounting problem of plastic waste
- 4912 reading nowCBC Investigates
B.C. gaming investigators repeatedly warned bosses of 'horrendous' money laundering
- 5821 reading now
Canada will grant asylum to Saudi woman fleeing alleged abuse: Trudeau